Transfer Learning

Most of the time you won't want to train a whole convolutional network yourself. Modern ConvNets training on huge datasets like ImageNet take weeks on multiple GPUs. Instead, most people use a pretrained network either as a fixed feature extractor, or as an initial network to fine tune. In this notebook, you'll be using VGGNet trained on the ImageNet dataset as a feature extractor. Below is a diagram of the VGGNet architecture.

VGGNet is great because it's simple and has great performance, coming in second in the ImageNet competition. The idea here is that we keep all the convolutional layers, but replace the final fully connected layers with our own classifier. This way we can use VGGNet as a feature extractor for our images then easily train a simple classifier on top of that. What we'll do is take the first fully connected layer with 4096 units, including thresholding with ReLUs. We can use those values as a code for each image, then build a classifier on top of those codes.

You can read more about transfer learning from the CS231n course notes.

Pretrained VGGNet

We'll be using a pretrained network from https://github.com/machrisaa/tensorflow-vgg. Make sure to clone this repository to the directory you're working from. You'll also want to rename it so it has an underscore instead of a dash.

git clone https://github.com/machrisaa/tensorflow-vgg.git tensorflow_vgg

This is a really nice implementation of VGGNet, quite easy to work with. The network has already been trained and the parameters are available from this link. You'll need to clone the repo into the folder containing this notebook. Then download the parameter file using the next cell.


In [5]:
from urllib.request import urlretrieve
from os.path import isfile, isdir
from tqdm import tqdm

vgg_dir = 'tensorflow_vgg/'
# Make sure vgg exists
if not isdir(vgg_dir):
    raise Exception("VGG directory doesn't exist!")

class DLProgress(tqdm):
    last_block = 0

    def hook(self, block_num=1, block_size=1, total_size=None):
        self.total = total_size
        self.update((block_num - self.last_block) * block_size)
        self.last_block = block_num

if not isfile(vgg_dir + "vgg16.npy"):
    with DLProgress(unit='B', unit_scale=True, miniters=1, desc='VGG16 Parameters') as pbar:
        urlretrieve(
            'https://s3.amazonaws.com/content.udacity-data.com/nd101/vgg16.npy',
            vgg_dir + 'vgg16.npy',
            pbar.hook)
else:
    print("Parameter file already exists!")


Parameter file already exists!

Flower power

Here we'll be using VGGNet to classify images of flowers. To get the flower dataset, run the cell below. This dataset comes from the TensorFlow inception tutorial.


In [8]:
import tarfile

dataset_folder_path = 'flower_photos'

class DLProgress(tqdm):
    last_block = 0

    def hook(self, block_num=1, block_size=1, total_size=None):
        self.total = total_size
        self.update((block_num - self.last_block) * block_size)
        self.last_block = block_num

if not isfile('flower_photos.tar.gz'):
    with DLProgress(unit='B', unit_scale=True, miniters=1, desc='Flowers Dataset') as pbar:
        urlretrieve(
            'http://download.tensorflow.org/example_images/flower_photos.tgz',
            'flower_photos.tar.gz',
            pbar.hook)

if not isdir(dataset_folder_path):
    with tarfile.open('flower_photos.tar.gz') as tar:
        tar.extractall()
        tar.close()

ConvNet Codes

Below, we'll run through all the images in our dataset and get codes for each of them. That is, we'll run the images through the VGGNet convolutional layers and record the values of the first fully connected layer. We can then write these to a file for later when we build our own classifier.

Here we're using the vgg16 module from tensorflow_vgg. The network takes images of size $244 \times 224 \times 3$ as input. Then it has 5 sets of convolutional layers. The network implemented here has this structure (copied from the source code:

self.conv1_1 = self.conv_layer(bgr, "conv1_1")
self.conv1_2 = self.conv_layer(self.conv1_1, "conv1_2")
self.pool1 = self.max_pool(self.conv1_2, 'pool1')

self.conv2_1 = self.conv_layer(self.pool1, "conv2_1")
self.conv2_2 = self.conv_layer(self.conv2_1, "conv2_2")
self.pool2 = self.max_pool(self.conv2_2, 'pool2')

self.conv3_1 = self.conv_layer(self.pool2, "conv3_1")
self.conv3_2 = self.conv_layer(self.conv3_1, "conv3_2")
self.conv3_3 = self.conv_layer(self.conv3_2, "conv3_3")
self.pool3 = self.max_pool(self.conv3_3, 'pool3')

self.conv4_1 = self.conv_layer(self.pool3, "conv4_1")
self.conv4_2 = self.conv_layer(self.conv4_1, "conv4_2")
self.conv4_3 = self.conv_layer(self.conv4_2, "conv4_3")
self.pool4 = self.max_pool(self.conv4_3, 'pool4')

self.conv5_1 = self.conv_layer(self.pool4, "conv5_1")
self.conv5_2 = self.conv_layer(self.conv5_1, "conv5_2")
self.conv5_3 = self.conv_layer(self.conv5_2, "conv5_3")
self.pool5 = self.max_pool(self.conv5_3, 'pool5')

self.fc6 = self.fc_layer(self.pool5, "fc6")
self.relu6 = tf.nn.relu(self.fc6)

So what we want are the values of the first fully connected layer, after being ReLUd (self.relu6). To build the network, we use

with tf.Session() as sess:
    vgg = vgg16.Vgg16()
    input_ = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, [None, 224, 224, 3])
    with tf.name_scope("content_vgg"):
        vgg.build(input_)

This creates the vgg object, then builds the graph with vgg.build(input_). Then to get the values from the layer,

feed_dict = {input_: images}
codes = sess.run(vgg.relu6, feed_dict=feed_dict)

In [11]:
import os

import numpy as np
import tensorflow as tf

from tensorflow_vgg import vgg16
from tensorflow_vgg import utils

In [3]:
data_dir = 'flower_photos/'
contents = os.listdir(data_dir)
classes = [each for each in contents if os.path.isdir(data_dir + each)]

Below I'm running images through the VGG network in batches.


In [5]:
batch_size = 100
codes_list = []
labels = []
batch = []

codes = None

with tf.Session() as sess:
    vgg = vgg16.Vgg16()
    input_ = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, [None, 224, 224, 3])
    with tf.name_scope("content_vgg"):
        vgg.build(input_)

    for each in classes:
        print("Starting {} images".format(each))
        class_path = data_dir + each
        files = os.listdir(class_path)
        for ii, file in enumerate(files, 1):
            # Add images to the current batch
            # utils.load_image crops the input images for us, from the center
            img = utils.load_image(os.path.join(class_path, file))
            batch.append(img.reshape((1, 224, 224, 3)))
            labels.append(each)
            
            # Running the batch through the network to get the codes
            if ii % batch_size == 0 or ii == len(files):
                images = np.concatenate(batch)

                feed_dict = {input_: images}
                codes_batch = sess.run(vgg.relu6, feed_dict=feed_dict)
                
                # Here I'm building an array of the codes
                if codes is None:
                    codes = codes_batch
                else:
                    codes = np.concatenate((codes, codes_batch))
                
                # Reset to start building the next batch
                batch = []
                print('{} images processed'.format(ii))


/home/mat/Projects/nd101/transfer_learning/tensorflow_vgg/vgg16.npy
npy file loaded
build model started
build model finished: 0s
Starting sunflowers images
100 images processed
200 images processed
300 images processed
400 images processed
500 images processed
600 images processed
699 images processed
Starting tulips images
100 images processed
200 images processed
300 images processed
400 images processed
500 images processed
600 images processed
700 images processed
799 images processed
Starting roses images
100 images processed
200 images processed
300 images processed
400 images processed
500 images processed
600 images processed
641 images processed
Starting daisy images
100 images processed
200 images processed
300 images processed
400 images processed
500 images processed
600 images processed
633 images processed
Starting dandelion images
100 images processed
200 images processed
300 images processed
400 images processed
500 images processed
600 images processed
700 images processed
800 images processed
898 images processed

In [6]:
# write codes to file
with open('codes', 'w') as f:
    codes.tofile(f)
    
# write labels to file
import csv
with open('labels', 'w') as f:
    writer = csv.writer(f, delimiter='\n')
    writer.writerow(labels)

Building the Classifier

Now that we have codes for all the images, we can build a simple classifier on top of them. The codes behave just like normal input into a simple neural network. Below I'm going to have you do most of the work.


In [12]:
# read codes and labels from file
import csv

with open('labels') as f:
    reader = csv.reader(f, delimiter='\n')
    labels = np.array([each for each in reader]).squeeze()
with open('codes') as f:
    codes = np.fromfile(f, dtype=np.float32)
    codes = codes.reshape((len(labels), -1))

Data prep

As usual, now we need to one-hot encode our labels and create validation/test sets. First up, creating our labels!

Exercise: From scikit-learn, use LabelBinarizer to create one-hot encoded vectors from the labels.


In [13]:
from sklearn.preprocessing import LabelBinarizer

lb = LabelBinarizer()
lb.fit(labels)

labels_vecs = lb.transform(labels)

Now you'll want to create your training, validation, and test sets. An important thing to note here is that our labels and data aren't randomized yet. We'll want to shuffle our data so the validation and test sets contain data from all classes. Otherwise, you could end up with testing sets that are all one class. Typically, you'll also want to make sure that each smaller set has the same the distribution of classes as it is for the whole data set. The easiest way to accomplish both these goals is to use StratifiedShuffleSplit from scikit-learn.

You can create the splitter like so:

ss = StratifiedShuffleSplit(n_splits=1, test_size=0.2)

Then split the data with

splitter = ss.split(x, y)

ss.split returns a generator of indices. You can pass the indices into the arrays to get the split sets. The fact that it's a generator means you either need to iterate over it, or use next(splitter) to get the indices. Be sure to read the documentation and the user guide.

Exercise: Use StratifiedShuffleSplit to split the codes and labels into training, validation, and test sets.


In [14]:
from sklearn.model_selection import StratifiedShuffleSplit

ss = StratifiedShuffleSplit(n_splits=1, test_size=0.2)

train_idx, val_idx = next(ss.split(codes, labels))

half_val_len = int(len(val_idx)/2)
val_idx, test_idx = val_idx[:half_val_len], val_idx[half_val_len:]

train_x, train_y = codes[train_idx], labels_vecs[train_idx]
val_x, val_y = codes[val_idx], labels_vecs[val_idx]
test_x, test_y = codes[test_idx], labels_vecs[test_idx]

In [18]:
print("Train shapes (x, y):", train_x.shape, train_y.shape)
print("Validation shapes (x, y):", val_x.shape, val_y.shape)
print("Test shapes (x, y):", test_x.shape, test_y.shape)


Train shapes (x, y): (2936, 4096) (2936, 5)
Validation shapes (x, y): (367, 4096) (367, 5)
Test shapes (x, y): (367, 4096) (367, 5)

If you did it right, you should see these sizes for the training sets:

Train shapes (x, y): (2936, 4096) (2936, 5)
Validation shapes (x, y): (367, 4096) (367, 5)
Test shapes (x, y): (367, 4096) (367, 5)

Classifier layers

Once you have the convolutional codes, you just need to build a classfier from some fully connected layers. You use the codes as the inputs and the image labels as targets. Otherwise the classifier is a typical neural network.

Exercise: With the codes and labels loaded, build the classifier. Consider the codes as your inputs, each of them are 4096D vectors. You'll want to use a hidden layer and an output layer as your classifier. Remember that the output layer needs to have one unit for each class and a softmax activation function. Use the cross entropy to calculate the cost.


In [12]:
inputs_ = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, shape=[None, codes.shape[1]])
labels_ = tf.placeholder(tf.int64, shape=[None, labels_vecs.shape[1]])

fc = tf.contrib.layers.fully_connected(inputs_, 256)
    
logits = tf.contrib.layers.fully_connected(fc, labels_vecs.shape[1], activation_fn=None)
cross_entropy = tf.nn.softmax_cross_entropy_with_logits(labels=labels_, logits=logits)
cost = tf.reduce_mean(cross_entropy)

optimizer = tf.train.AdamOptimizer().minimize(cost)

predicted = tf.nn.softmax(logits)
correct_pred = tf.equal(tf.argmax(predicted, 1), tf.argmax(labels_, 1))
accuracy = tf.reduce_mean(tf.cast(correct_pred, tf.float32))

Batches!

Here is just a simple way to do batches. I've written it so that it includes all the data. Sometimes you'll throw out some data at the end to make sure you have full batches. Here I just extend the last batch to include the remaining data.


In [11]:
def get_batches(x, y, n_batches=10):
    """ Return a generator that yields batches from arrays x and y. """
    batch_size = len(x)//n_batches
    
    for ii in range(0, n_batches*batch_size, batch_size):
        # If we're not on the last batch, grab data with size batch_size
        if ii != (n_batches-1)*batch_size:
            X, Y = x[ii: ii+batch_size], y[ii: ii+batch_size] 
        # On the last batch, grab the rest of the data
        else:
            X, Y = x[ii:], y[ii:]
        # I love generators
        yield X, Y

Training

Here, we'll train the network.

Exercise: So far we've been providing the training code for you. Here, I'm going to give you a bit more of a challenge and have you write the code to train the network. Of course, you'll be able to see my solution if you need help.


In [13]:
epochs = 10
iteration = 0
saver = tf.train.Saver()
with tf.Session() as sess:
    
    sess.run(tf.global_variables_initializer())
    for e in range(epochs):
        for x, y in get_batches(train_x, train_y):
            feed = {inputs_: x,
                    labels_: y}
            loss, _ = sess.run([cost, optimizer], feed_dict=feed)
            print("Epoch: {}/{}".format(e+1, epochs),
                  "Iteration: {}".format(iteration),
                  "Training loss: {:.5f}".format(loss))
            iteration += 1
            
            if iteration % 5 == 0:
                feed = {inputs_: val_x,
                        labels_: val_y}
                val_acc = sess.run(accuracy, feed_dict=feed)
                print("Epoch: {}/{}".format(e, epochs),
                      "Iteration: {}".format(iteration),
                      "Validation Acc: {:.4f}".format(val_acc))
    saver.save(sess, "checkpoints/flowers.ckpt")


Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 0 Training loss: 7.62348
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 1 Training loss: 10.32786
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 2 Training loss: 21.35359
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 3 Training loss: 12.31110
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 4 Training loss: 8.31277
Epoch: 0/10 Iteration: 5 Validation Acc: 0.5477
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 5 Training loss: 5.92110
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 6 Training loss: 4.99467
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 7 Training loss: 1.99741
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 8 Training loss: 1.94462
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 9 Training loss: 1.51370
Epoch: 0/10 Iteration: 10 Validation Acc: 0.7084
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 10 Training loss: 1.31684
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 11 Training loss: 1.32172
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 12 Training loss: 1.41460
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 13 Training loss: 0.99157
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 14 Training loss: 0.91047
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 15 Validation Acc: 0.8065
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 15 Training loss: 0.78869
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 16 Training loss: 0.70985
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 17 Training loss: 0.79340
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 18 Training loss: 0.68372
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 19 Training loss: 0.51544
Epoch: 1/10 Iteration: 20 Validation Acc: 0.8256
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 20 Training loss: 0.48783
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 21 Training loss: 0.32039
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 22 Training loss: 0.40365
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 23 Training loss: 0.58335
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 24 Training loss: 0.54804
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 25 Validation Acc: 0.8529
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 25 Training loss: 0.34388
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 26 Training loss: 0.48099
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 27 Training loss: 0.44454
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 28 Training loss: 0.39410
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 29 Training loss: 0.31900
Epoch: 2/10 Iteration: 30 Validation Acc: 0.8610
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 30 Training loss: 0.34356
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 31 Training loss: 0.24606
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 32 Training loss: 0.22955
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 33 Training loss: 0.25774
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 34 Training loss: 0.21911
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 35 Validation Acc: 0.8638
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 35 Training loss: 0.29131
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 36 Training loss: 0.23891
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 37 Training loss: 0.31079
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 38 Training loss: 0.23009
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 39 Training loss: 0.25174
Epoch: 3/10 Iteration: 40 Validation Acc: 0.8692
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 40 Training loss: 0.24947
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 41 Training loss: 0.17203
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 42 Training loss: 0.15461
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 43 Training loss: 0.16060
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 44 Training loss: 0.14797
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 45 Validation Acc: 0.8828
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 45 Training loss: 0.17663
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 46 Training loss: 0.19410
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 47 Training loss: 0.18809
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 48 Training loss: 0.16295
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 49 Training loss: 0.14726
Epoch: 4/10 Iteration: 50 Validation Acc: 0.8828
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 50 Training loss: 0.15666
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 51 Training loss: 0.11006
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 52 Training loss: 0.11478
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 53 Training loss: 0.12485
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 54 Training loss: 0.13628
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 55 Validation Acc: 0.8856
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 55 Training loss: 0.10149
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 56 Training loss: 0.12165
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 57 Training loss: 0.12114
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 58 Training loss: 0.11902
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 59 Training loss: 0.10256
Epoch: 5/10 Iteration: 60 Validation Acc: 0.9019
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 60 Training loss: 0.11186
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 61 Training loss: 0.06356
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 62 Training loss: 0.07796
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 63 Training loss: 0.08024
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 64 Training loss: 0.08772
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 65 Validation Acc: 0.8992
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 65 Training loss: 0.09512
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 66 Training loss: 0.08547
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 67 Training loss: 0.08294
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 68 Training loss: 0.08804
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 69 Training loss: 0.07284
Epoch: 6/10 Iteration: 70 Validation Acc: 0.8992
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 70 Training loss: 0.08614
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 71 Training loss: 0.04417
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 72 Training loss: 0.05823
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 73 Training loss: 0.05555
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 74 Training loss: 0.06809
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 75 Validation Acc: 0.8937
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 75 Training loss: 0.07684
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 76 Training loss: 0.06628
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 77 Training loss: 0.05478
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 78 Training loss: 0.06544
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 79 Training loss: 0.05331
Epoch: 7/10 Iteration: 80 Validation Acc: 0.8992
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 80 Training loss: 0.05898
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 81 Training loss: 0.03265
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 82 Training loss: 0.05069
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 83 Training loss: 0.04249
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 84 Training loss: 0.05586
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 85 Validation Acc: 0.9019
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 85 Training loss: 0.05478
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 86 Training loss: 0.04740
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 87 Training loss: 0.04257
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 88 Training loss: 0.04643
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 89 Training loss: 0.04168
Epoch: 8/10 Iteration: 90 Validation Acc: 0.8992
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 90 Training loss: 0.04356
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 91 Training loss: 0.02476
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 92 Training loss: 0.03789
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 93 Training loss: 0.03307
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 94 Training loss: 0.04144
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 95 Validation Acc: 0.8992
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 95 Training loss: 0.04494
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 96 Training loss: 0.03619
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 97 Training loss: 0.03251
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 98 Training loss: 0.03605
Epoch: 10/10 Iteration: 99 Training loss: 0.03234
Epoch: 9/10 Iteration: 100 Validation Acc: 0.9019

Testing

Below you see the test accuracy. You can also see the predictions returned for images.


In [14]:
with tf.Session() as sess:
    saver.restore(sess, tf.train.latest_checkpoint('checkpoints'))
    
    feed = {inputs_: test_x,
            labels_: test_y}
    test_acc = sess.run(accuracy, feed_dict=feed)
    print("Test accuracy: {:.4f}".format(test_acc))


Test accuracy: 0.8747

In [15]:
%matplotlib inline

import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
from scipy.ndimage import imread

Below, feel free to choose images and see how the trained classifier predicts the flowers in them.


In [23]:
test_img_path = 'flower_photos/roses/10894627425_ec76bbc757_n.jpg'
test_img = imread(test_img_path)
plt.imshow(test_img)


Out[23]:
<matplotlib.image.AxesImage at 0x7fca866c7240>

In [12]:
# Run this cell if you don't have a vgg graph built
with tf.Session() as sess:
    input_ = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, [None, 224, 224, 3])
    vgg = vgg16.Vgg16()
    vgg.build(input_)


/home/mat/Projects/nd101/transfer_learning/tensorflow_vgg/vgg16.npy
npy file loaded
build model started
build model finished: 0s

In [24]:
with tf.Session() as sess:
    img = utils.load_image(test_img_path)
    img = img.reshape((1, 224, 224, 3))

    feed_dict = {input_: img}
    code = sess.run(vgg.relu6, feed_dict=feed_dict)
        
saver = tf.train.Saver()
with tf.Session() as sess:
    saver.restore(sess, tf.train.latest_checkpoint('checkpoints'))
    
    feed = {inputs_: code}
    prediction = sess.run(predicted, feed_dict=feed).squeeze()

In [25]:
plt.imshow(test_img)


Out[25]:
<matplotlib.image.AxesImage at 0x7fca865f6cf8>

In [26]:
plt.barh(np.arange(5), prediction)
_ = plt.yticks(np.arange(5), lb.classes_)