In [1]:
library(data.table)

In [2]:
## Using a table of article assessments and views, build tables
## (matrices) that shows the number of dissonant articles per
## assessment category based on sorting by popularity.
##
## The underlying assumption is that in an ideal system with a limited
## and fixed amount of resources (in other words, popularity and high quality
## artefacts does not increase the amount of resources in the system),
## popularity ranking and assessment class follow a 1-to-1 relationship.
## We can therefore sort by popularity and group articles that way
## because work will be prioritised by popularity.

## DATA ASSUMPTION: views_with_redirects from resolve-redirects.R
## is loaded into memory.

## 3: build a 2x2 matrix of assessment classes and popularity classes
## 

## Assessment classes in ascending order of quality.

In [3]:
assessment_classes = c('E', 'D', 'C', 'B', 'A');

In [4]:
quality_prediction_and_page_views <- read.table("../../results/sql_queries/entity_views_and_aggregated_revisions/entity_views_and_aggregated_revisions_and_quality_scoring_20130101.tsv", header=FALSE, sep="\t")

In [5]:
quality_prediction_and_page_views <- data.table(quality_prediction_and_page_views)

In [6]:
colnames(quality_prediction_and_page_views) <- c('entity_id','number_of_revisions', 'page_views', 'prediction')

In [7]:
summary(quality_prediction_and_page_views)


    entity_id       number_of_revisions   page_views        prediction 
 Q1      :      1   Min.   :   1.00     Min.   :0.000e+00   C:   1901  
 Q100    :      1   1st Qu.:  18.00     1st Qu.:5.050e+02   D: 100523  
 Q1000   :      1   Median :  32.00     Median :2.761e+03   E:1914529  
 Q10000  :      1   Mean   :  43.29     Mean   :1.787e+05              
 Q100000 :      1   3rd Qu.:  57.00     3rd Qu.:1.731e+04              
 Q1000000:      1   Max.   :3152.00     Max.   :1.253e+10              
 (Other) :2016947                                                      

In [8]:
## 0: calculate number of articles in each assessment class
n_per_class = quality_prediction_and_page_views[, list(narticles=sum(.N)), by='prediction']

In [9]:
setkey(n_per_class, prediction);
## NOTE: setkey allows us to do n_per_class['GA']$narticles to get counts

In [10]:
## 1: order articles by popularity
articles_by_pop = quality_prediction_and_page_views[order(quality_prediction_and_page_views$page_views)][,list(entity_id, prediction, page_views)];

In [11]:
## 2: assign popularity assessment class based on rank
##   (buckets based on number of articles in each class)
articles_by_pop[, pop_class := ''];
articles_by_pop[, seqNum := seq_len(nrow(articles_by_pop))];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_class
Q2107007E 0
Q1491146E 0
Q2000513E 0
Q1592439E 0
Q157851 E 0
Q1592660E 0
Q1863926E 0
Q1614688E 0
Q1671151E 0
Q623445 E 0
Q1832777E 0
Q1832778E 0
Q2140321E 0
Q1600718E 0
Q999283 E 0
Q2012014E 0
Q1832769E 0
Q1383775E 0
Q2112953E 0
Q2062993E 0
Q1295789E 0
Q1431656E 0
Q1855612E 0
Q1420551E 0
Q1115208E 0
Q1470972E 0
Q1855663E 0
Q1729710E 0
Q965167 E 0
Q1594973E 0
Q116933 E 2047137765
Q171186 E 2047579662
Q356 D 2047631596
Q829984 E 2047695596
Q384060 E 2047954248
Q1048694 E 2048095025
Q31165 E 2048330818
Q40629 E 2049755644
Q105584 E 2049926923
Q565 D 2052996261
Q1868372 E 2056080224
Q209330 E 2060928966
Q14005 D 2063120071
Q918 D 2063217449
Q150248 E 2068796814
Q866 D 2079749157
Q477675 E 2080785713
Q1967876 E 2084215818
Q750403 E 2084693498
Q355 D 2093900731
Q623578 E 2097991400
Q33999 E 2108672678
Q193563 E 2130725560
Q423048 E 2136131564
Q37312 E 2142913121
Q54919 D 2148531382
Q36578 D 2229315598
Q30 D 2277746226
Q5 C 5668008721
Q5296 D 12530369761
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNum
Q2107007E 0 1
Q1491146E 0 2
Q2000513E 0 3
Q1592439E 0 4
Q157851 E 0 5
Q1592660E 0 6
Q1863926E 0 7
Q1614688E 0 8
Q1671151E 0 9
Q623445 E 0 10
Q1832777E 0 11
Q1832778E 0 12
Q2140321E 0 13
Q1600718E 0 14
Q999283 E 0 15
Q2012014E 0 16
Q1832769E 0 17
Q1383775E 0 18
Q2112953E 0 19
Q2062993E 0 20
Q1295789E 0 21
Q1431656E 0 22
Q1855612E 0 23
Q1420551E 0 24
Q1115208E 0 25
Q1470972E 0 26
Q1855663E 0 27
Q1729710E 0 28
Q965167 E 0 29
Q1594973E 0 30
Q116933 E 2047137765 2016924
Q171186 E 2047579662 2016925
Q356 D 2047631596 2016926
Q829984 E 2047695596 2016927
Q384060 E 2047954248 2016928
Q1048694 E 2048095025 2016929
Q31165 E 2048330818 2016930
Q40629 E 2049755644 2016931
Q105584 E 2049926923 2016932
Q565 D 2052996261 2016933
Q1868372 E 2056080224 2016934
Q209330 E 2060928966 2016935
Q14005 D 2063120071 2016936
Q918 D 2063217449 2016937
Q150248 E 2068796814 2016938
Q866 D 2079749157 2016939
Q477675 E 2080785713 2016940
Q1967876 E 2084215818 2016941
Q750403 E 2084693498 2016942
Q355 D 2093900731 2016943
Q623578 E 2097991400 2016944
Q33999 E 2108672678 2016945
Q193563 E 2130725560 2016946
Q423048 E 2136131564 2016947
Q37312 E 2142913121 2016948
Q54919 D 2148531382 2016949
Q36578 D 2229315598 2016950
Q30 D 2277746226 2016951
Q5 C 5668008721 2016952
Q5296 D 12530369761 2016953

In [12]:
assign_pop_class = function(dataset, classes, class_n) {
  ## Based on the per-class number of articles in class_n
  ## assign popularity based on classes to dataset.
  prev_idx = 0;
  for(rating in classes) {
    start_idx = prev_idx + 1;
    end_idx = start_idx + class_n[prediction == rating]$narticles;
    print(paste('start_idx =', start_idx, ', end_idx = ', end_idx));
    dataset[seqNum >= start_idx & seqNum <= end_idx, pop_class := rating];
    prev_idx = end_idx -1;
  }
  dataset;
}

In [13]:
articles_by_pop = assign_pop_class(articles_by_pop,
  assessment_classes, n_per_class);


[1] "start_idx = 1 , end_idx =  1914530"
[1] "start_idx = 1914530 , end_idx =  2015053"
[1] "start_idx = 2015053 , end_idx =  2016954"
[1] "start_idx = 2016954 , end_idx =  "
[1] "start_idx =  , end_idx =  "

In [14]:
create_dissonance_matrix = function(articledata, classes) {
  d_mtrx = matrix(0, nrow=length(classes), ncol=length(classes));
  rownames(d_mtrx) = classes;
  colnames(d_mtrx) = classes;

  for(real_rating in classes) {
    for(pop_rating in classes) {
      d_mtrx[real_rating, pop_rating] = length(articledata[prediction == real_rating & pop_class == pop_rating]$entity_id);
    }
  }
  d_mtrx;
}

In [15]:
## Based on direct hits to articles:
create_dissonance_matrix(articles_by_pop, assessment_classes)


EDCBA
E182064892742 1139 0 0
D 92551 7226 746 0 0
C 1330 555 16 0 0
B 0 0 0 0 0
A 0 0 0 0 0

In [16]:
dissonance_matrix = create_dissonance_matrix(articles_by_pop,
  assessment_classes);

In [17]:
# Total misaligned entities
(dissonance_matrix[1,1]+dissonance_matrix[2,2]+dissonance_matrix[3,3]+dissonance_matrix[4,4]+dissonance_matrix[5,5])/sum(dissonance_matrix[,])


0.90626306116206

In [18]:
# A class quality and A class views over A class quality
dissonance_matrix[5,5]/sum(dissonance_matrix[5,])


NaN

In [19]:
# A class quality and E and D class views over A class quality
(dissonance_matrix[5,1]+dissonance_matrix[5,2])/sum(dissonance_matrix[5,])


NaN

In [20]:
# A class quality and < A class views
(dissonance_matrix[5,1]+dissonance_matrix[5,2]+dissonance_matrix[5,3]+dissonance_matrix[5,4])/sum(dissonance_matrix[5,])


NaN

In [21]:
# < A class quality and A class views
(dissonance_matrix[1,5]+dissonance_matrix[2,5]+dissonance_matrix[3,5]+dissonance_matrix[4,5])/sum(dissonance_matrix[,5])


NaN

In [22]:
prediction_e_pop_class_a <- merge(articles_by_pop[prediction == 'E' & pop_class == 'A'],quality_prediction_and_page_views, by='entity_id')[, c("entity_id","page_views.x", "number_of_revisions")]

In [23]:
head(prediction_e_pop_class_a)


entity_idpage_views.xnumber_of_revisions

In [24]:
## Q: why do I get _two_ pageid columns?  Solution is to do the selection
## on the joined table, not as a select _in_ the join.

## Dissonance matrix proportions by row (..., 1) and column (..., 2)
## rounded to 1 decimal places.

In [25]:
round(100*prop.table(dissonance_matrix, 1), 1);


EDCBA
E95.1 4.80.1 0 0
D92.1 7.20.7 0 0
C70.029.20.8 0 0
B NaN NaNNaN NaN NaN
A NaN NaNNaN NaN NaN

In [26]:
round(100*prop.table(dissonance_matrix, 2), 1);


EDCBA
E95.192.359.9NaN NaN
D 4.8 7.239.2NaN NaN
C 0.1 0.6 0.8NaN NaN
B 0.0 0.0 0.0NaN NaN
A 0.0 0.0 0.0NaN NaN

In [27]:
## Let's write the stubs out to a file
write.table(merge(articles_by_pop[(prediction == 'E' | prediction == 'D' | prediction == 'C' | prediction == 'B') & pop_class == 'A'], quality_prediction_and_page_views, by='entity_id')[, c("entity_id","pop_class", "prediction.x")],
           '../../results/entity_categorization/201301_a_class_views_less_than_a_quality.tsv', row.names=FALSE, col.names=FALSE, quote=FALSE, sep='\t');
merge(articles_by_pop[(prediction == 'E' | prediction == 'D' | prediction == 'C' | prediction == 'B') & pop_class == 'A'], quality_prediction_and_page_views, by='entity_id')[, c("entity_id","pop_class", "prediction.x")]


entity_idpop_classprediction.x

In [28]:
write.table(merge(articles_by_pop[prediction == 'A' & (pop_class == 'B' | pop_class == 'C' | pop_class == 'D' | pop_class == 'E')], quality_prediction_and_page_views, by='entity_id')[, c("entity_id","pop_class", "prediction.x")],
           '../../results/entity_categorization/201301_a_class_quality_less_than_a_views.tsv', row.names=FALSE, col.names=FALSE, quote=FALSE, sep='\t');

In [29]:
write.table(merge(articles_by_pop[(prediction == 'A' & pop_class == 'A') | (prediction == 'B' & pop_class == 'B') | (prediction == 'C' & pop_class == 'C') | (prediction == 'D' & pop_class == 'D') | (prediction == 'E' & pop_class == 'E')], quality_prediction_and_page_views, by='entity_id')[, c("entity_id","pop_class", "prediction.x")],
           '../../results/entity_categorization/201301_aligned.tsv', row.names=FALSE, col.names=FALSE, quote=FALSE, sep='\t');

In [30]:
write.table(merge(articles_by_pop[(prediction == 'A' & pop_class != 'A') | (prediction == 'B' & pop_class != 'B') | (prediction == 'C' & pop_class != 'C') | (prediction == 'D' & pop_class != 'D') | (prediction == 'E' & pop_class != 'E')], quality_prediction_and_page_views, by='entity_id')[, c("entity_id","pop_class", "prediction.x")],
           '../../results/entity_categorization/201301_misaligned.tsv', row.names=FALSE, col.names=FALSE, quote=FALSE, sep='\t');

Dissonance Measures (was seperate file)


In [29]:
## Various ways of measuring dissonance.

## DATA ASSUMPTION: articles_by_pop from build-dissonance-table.R
## is loaded into memory.

## None/Moderate/High measure of dissonance

In [30]:
articles_by_pop[, pop_class := ordered(pop_class, assessment_classes)];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNum
Q2107007E 0 E 1
Q1491146E 0 E 2
Q2000513E 0 E 3
Q1592439E 0 E 4
Q157851 E 0 E 5
Q1592660E 0 E 6
Q1863926E 0 E 7
Q1614688E 0 E 8
Q1671151E 0 E 9
Q623445 E 0 E 10
Q1832777E 0 E 11
Q1832778E 0 E 12
Q2140321E 0 E 13
Q1600718E 0 E 14
Q999283 E 0 E 15
Q2012014E 0 E 16
Q1832769E 0 E 17
Q1383775E 0 E 18
Q2112953E 0 E 19
Q2062993E 0 E 20
Q1295789E 0 E 21
Q1431656E 0 E 22
Q1855612E 0 E 23
Q1420551E 0 E 24
Q1115208E 0 E 25
Q1470972E 0 E 26
Q1855663E 0 E 27
Q1729710E 0 E 28
Q965167 E 0 E 29
Q1594973E 0 E 30
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953

In [31]:
dissonance_metric = c('High negative', 'Moderate negative',
  'None', 'Moderate positive', 'High positive');

In [32]:
articles_by_pop[, dissonance := factor(NA, dissonance_metric)];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA

In [33]:
## NOTE: because pop_class is of class ordered, we can use
##       expressions like "pop_class < 'C'" as expected

In [34]:
## A: None if A, Moderate if A, High elsewhere
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'A' & pop_class <= 'C',
                dissonance := 'High negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'A' & pop_class == 'B',
                dissonance := 'Moderate negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'A' & pop_class == 'A',
                dissonance := 'None'];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA

In [35]:
## B: 
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'B' & pop_class <= 'D',
                dissonance := 'High negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'B' & pop_class == 'C',
                dissonance := 'Moderate negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'B' & pop_class == 'B',
                dissonance := 'None'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'B' & pop_class == 'A',
                dissonance := 'Moderate positive'];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA

In [36]:
## C: 
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'C' & pop_class == 'E',
                dissonance := 'High negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'C' & pop_class == 'D',
                dissonance := 'Moderate negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'C' & pop_class == 'C',
                dissonance := 'None'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'C' & pop_class == 'B',
                dissonance := 'Moderate positive'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'C' & pop_class == 'A',
                dissonance := 'High positive'];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 NA
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA

In [37]:
## D
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'D' & pop_class == 'E',
                dissonance := 'Moderate negative'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'D' & pop_class == 'D',
                dissonance := 'None'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'D' & pop_class == 'C',
                dissonance := 'Moderate positive'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'D' & pop_class >= 'B',
                dissonance := 'High positive'];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596C 2016926 NA
Q829984 E 2047695596C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261C 2016933 NA
Q1868372 E 2056080224C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071C 2016936 NA
Q918 D 2063217449C 2016937 NA
Q150248 E 2068796814C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157C 2016939 NA
Q477675 E 2080785713C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731C 2016943 NA
Q623578 E 2097991400C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382C 2016949 NA
Q36578 D 2229315598C 2016950 NA
Q30 D 2277746226C 2016951 NA
Q5 C 5668008721C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761C 2016953 NA
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765 C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662 C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596 C 2016926 Moderate positive
Q829984 E 2047695596 C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248 C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025 C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818 C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644 C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923 C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261 C 2016933 Moderate positive
Q1868372 E 2056080224 C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966 C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071 C 2016936 Moderate positive
Q918 D 2063217449 C 2016937 Moderate positive
Q150248 E 2068796814 C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157 C 2016939 Moderate positive
Q477675 E 2080785713 C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818 C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498 C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731 C 2016943 Moderate positive
Q623578 E 2097991400 C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678 C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560 C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564 C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121 C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382 C 2016949 Moderate positive
Q36578 D 2229315598 C 2016950 Moderate positive
Q30 D 2277746226 C 2016951 Moderate positive
Q5 C 5668008721 C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761 C 2016953 Moderate positive
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 NA
Q1491146E 0 E 2 NA
Q2000513E 0 E 3 NA
Q1592439E 0 E 4 NA
Q157851 E 0 E 5 NA
Q1592660E 0 E 6 NA
Q1863926E 0 E 7 NA
Q1614688E 0 E 8 NA
Q1671151E 0 E 9 NA
Q623445 E 0 E 10 NA
Q1832777E 0 E 11 NA
Q1832778E 0 E 12 NA
Q2140321E 0 E 13 NA
Q1600718E 0 E 14 NA
Q999283 E 0 E 15 NA
Q2012014E 0 E 16 NA
Q1832769E 0 E 17 NA
Q1383775E 0 E 18 NA
Q2112953E 0 E 19 NA
Q2062993E 0 E 20 NA
Q1295789E 0 E 21 NA
Q1431656E 0 E 22 NA
Q1855612E 0 E 23 NA
Q1420551E 0 E 24 NA
Q1115208E 0 E 25 NA
Q1470972E 0 E 26 NA
Q1855663E 0 E 27 NA
Q1729710E 0 E 28 NA
Q965167 E 0 E 29 NA
Q1594973E 0 E 30 NA
Q116933 E 2047137765 C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662 C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596 C 2016926 Moderate positive
Q829984 E 2047695596 C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248 C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025 C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818 C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644 C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923 C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261 C 2016933 Moderate positive
Q1868372 E 2056080224 C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966 C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071 C 2016936 Moderate positive
Q918 D 2063217449 C 2016937 Moderate positive
Q150248 E 2068796814 C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157 C 2016939 Moderate positive
Q477675 E 2080785713 C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818 C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498 C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731 C 2016943 Moderate positive
Q623578 E 2097991400 C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678 C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560 C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564 C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121 C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382 C 2016949 Moderate positive
Q36578 D 2229315598 C 2016950 Moderate positive
Q30 D 2277746226 C 2016951 Moderate positive
Q5 C 5668008721 C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761 C 2016953 Moderate positive

In [38]:
## E
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'E' & pop_class == 'E',
                dissonance := 'None'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'E' & pop_class == 'D',
                dissonance := 'Moderate positive'];
articles_by_pop[prediction == 'E' & pop_class >= 'C',
                dissonance := 'High positive'];


entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 None
Q1491146E 0 E 2 None
Q2000513E 0 E 3 None
Q1592439E 0 E 4 None
Q157851 E 0 E 5 None
Q1592660E 0 E 6 None
Q1863926E 0 E 7 None
Q1614688E 0 E 8 None
Q1671151E 0 E 9 None
Q623445 E 0 E 10 None
Q1832777E 0 E 11 None
Q1832778E 0 E 12 None
Q2140321E 0 E 13 None
Q1600718E 0 E 14 None
Q999283 E 0 E 15 None
Q2012014E 0 E 16 None
Q1832769E 0 E 17 None
Q1383775E 0 E 18 None
Q2112953E 0 E 19 None
Q2062993E 0 E 20 None
Q1295789E 0 E 21 None
Q1431656E 0 E 22 None
Q1855612E 0 E 23 None
Q1420551E 0 E 24 None
Q1115208E 0 E 25 None
Q1470972E 0 E 26 None
Q1855663E 0 E 27 None
Q1729710E 0 E 28 None
Q965167 E 0 E 29 None
Q1594973E 0 E 30 None
Q116933 E 2047137765 C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662 C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596 C 2016926 Moderate positive
Q829984 E 2047695596 C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248 C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025 C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818 C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644 C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923 C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261 C 2016933 Moderate positive
Q1868372 E 2056080224 C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966 C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071 C 2016936 Moderate positive
Q918 D 2063217449 C 2016937 Moderate positive
Q150248 E 2068796814 C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157 C 2016939 Moderate positive
Q477675 E 2080785713 C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818 C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498 C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731 C 2016943 Moderate positive
Q623578 E 2097991400 C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678 C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560 C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564 C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121 C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382 C 2016949 Moderate positive
Q36578 D 2229315598 C 2016950 Moderate positive
Q30 D 2277746226 C 2016951 Moderate positive
Q5 C 5668008721 C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761 C 2016953 Moderate positive
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 None
Q1491146E 0 E 2 None
Q2000513E 0 E 3 None
Q1592439E 0 E 4 None
Q157851 E 0 E 5 None
Q1592660E 0 E 6 None
Q1863926E 0 E 7 None
Q1614688E 0 E 8 None
Q1671151E 0 E 9 None
Q623445 E 0 E 10 None
Q1832777E 0 E 11 None
Q1832778E 0 E 12 None
Q2140321E 0 E 13 None
Q1600718E 0 E 14 None
Q999283 E 0 E 15 None
Q2012014E 0 E 16 None
Q1832769E 0 E 17 None
Q1383775E 0 E 18 None
Q2112953E 0 E 19 None
Q2062993E 0 E 20 None
Q1295789E 0 E 21 None
Q1431656E 0 E 22 None
Q1855612E 0 E 23 None
Q1420551E 0 E 24 None
Q1115208E 0 E 25 None
Q1470972E 0 E 26 None
Q1855663E 0 E 27 None
Q1729710E 0 E 28 None
Q965167 E 0 E 29 None
Q1594973E 0 E 30 None
Q116933 E 2047137765 C 2016924 NA
Q171186 E 2047579662 C 2016925 NA
Q356 D 2047631596 C 2016926 Moderate positive
Q829984 E 2047695596 C 2016927 NA
Q384060 E 2047954248 C 2016928 NA
Q1048694 E 2048095025 C 2016929 NA
Q31165 E 2048330818 C 2016930 NA
Q40629 E 2049755644 C 2016931 NA
Q105584 E 2049926923 C 2016932 NA
Q565 D 2052996261 C 2016933 Moderate positive
Q1868372 E 2056080224 C 2016934 NA
Q209330 E 2060928966 C 2016935 NA
Q14005 D 2063120071 C 2016936 Moderate positive
Q918 D 2063217449 C 2016937 Moderate positive
Q150248 E 2068796814 C 2016938 NA
Q866 D 2079749157 C 2016939 Moderate positive
Q477675 E 2080785713 C 2016940 NA
Q1967876 E 2084215818 C 2016941 NA
Q750403 E 2084693498 C 2016942 NA
Q355 D 2093900731 C 2016943 Moderate positive
Q623578 E 2097991400 C 2016944 NA
Q33999 E 2108672678 C 2016945 NA
Q193563 E 2130725560 C 2016946 NA
Q423048 E 2136131564 C 2016947 NA
Q37312 E 2142913121 C 2016948 NA
Q54919 D 2148531382 C 2016949 Moderate positive
Q36578 D 2229315598 C 2016950 Moderate positive
Q30 D 2277746226 C 2016951 Moderate positive
Q5 C 5668008721 C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761 C 2016953 Moderate positive
entity_idpredictionpage_viewspop_classseqNumdissonance
Q2107007E 0 E 1 None
Q1491146E 0 E 2 None
Q2000513E 0 E 3 None
Q1592439E 0 E 4 None
Q157851 E 0 E 5 None
Q1592660E 0 E 6 None
Q1863926E 0 E 7 None
Q1614688E 0 E 8 None
Q1671151E 0 E 9 None
Q623445 E 0 E 10 None
Q1832777E 0 E 11 None
Q1832778E 0 E 12 None
Q2140321E 0 E 13 None
Q1600718E 0 E 14 None
Q999283 E 0 E 15 None
Q2012014E 0 E 16 None
Q1832769E 0 E 17 None
Q1383775E 0 E 18 None
Q2112953E 0 E 19 None
Q2062993E 0 E 20 None
Q1295789E 0 E 21 None
Q1431656E 0 E 22 None
Q1855612E 0 E 23 None
Q1420551E 0 E 24 None
Q1115208E 0 E 25 None
Q1470972E 0 E 26 None
Q1855663E 0 E 27 None
Q1729710E 0 E 28 None
Q965167 E 0 E 29 None
Q1594973E 0 E 30 None
Q116933 E 2047137765 C 2016924 High positive
Q171186 E 2047579662 C 2016925 High positive
Q356 D 2047631596 C 2016926 Moderate positive
Q829984 E 2047695596 C 2016927 High positive
Q384060 E 2047954248 C 2016928 High positive
Q1048694 E 2048095025 C 2016929 High positive
Q31165 E 2048330818 C 2016930 High positive
Q40629 E 2049755644 C 2016931 High positive
Q105584 E 2049926923 C 2016932 High positive
Q565 D 2052996261 C 2016933 Moderate positive
Q1868372 E 2056080224 C 2016934 High positive
Q209330 E 2060928966 C 2016935 High positive
Q14005 D 2063120071 C 2016936 Moderate positive
Q918 D 2063217449 C 2016937 Moderate positive
Q150248 E 2068796814 C 2016938 High positive
Q866 D 2079749157 C 2016939 Moderate positive
Q477675 E 2080785713 C 2016940 High positive
Q1967876 E 2084215818 C 2016941 High positive
Q750403 E 2084693498 C 2016942 High positive
Q355 D 2093900731 C 2016943 Moderate positive
Q623578 E 2097991400 C 2016944 High positive
Q33999 E 2108672678 C 2016945 High positive
Q193563 E 2130725560 C 2016946 High positive
Q423048 E 2136131564 C 2016947 High positive
Q37312 E 2142913121 C 2016948 High positive
Q54919 D 2148531382 C 2016949 Moderate positive
Q36578 D 2229315598 C 2016950 Moderate positive
Q30 D 2277746226 C 2016951 Moderate positive
Q5 C 5668008721 C 2016952 None
Q5296 D 12530369761 C 2016953 Moderate positive

In [39]:
## Build a matrix where columns are the metric and rows are classes
create_alt_diss_matrix = function(articledata, metric, classes) {
  d_mtrx = matrix(0, nrow=length(classes), ncol=length(metric));
  rownames(d_mtrx) = classes;
  colnames(d_mtrx) = metric;

  ## NOTE: R matrix values are [row,col] dimensions
  for(real_rating in classes) {
    for(diss_rating in metric) {
      d_mtrx[real_rating, diss_rating] = length(articledata[prediction == real_rating & dissonance == diss_rating]$entity_id);
    }
  }
  d_mtrx;
}

alternative_dissonance_matrix.1 = create_alt_diss_matrix(articles_by_pop,
  dissonance_metric, assessment_classes);

In [40]:
## Normalise by row
round(100*prop.table(alternative_dissonance_matrix.1, 1), 1);


High negativeModerate negativeNoneModerate positiveHigh positive
E 0 0.095.14.8 0.1
D 0 92.1 7.20.7 0.0
C 70 29.2 0.80.0 0.0
BNaN NaN NaNNaN NaN
ANaN NaN NaNNaN NaN

In [41]:
## Number of dissonant views per assessment class and amount of dissonance
articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(prediction, dissonance)];


predictiondissonancedissonant_views
E None 31210714974
D Moderate negative 1827036865
C High negative 70882872
E Moderate positive 84315454843
D None 12219875368
C Moderate negative 465289797
E High positive 166479713194
D Moderate positive 57375950077
C None 6406444077

In [42]:
## Calculations of total number of dissonant views per dissonance
articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(dissonance)];


dissonancedissonant_views
None 49837034419
Moderate negative 2292326662
High negative 70882872
Moderate positive141691404920
High positive 166479713194

In [43]:
articles_by_pop[,sum(as.numeric(page_views))];


360371362067

In [44]:
## Proportions
100*65938379920/545180810059;
100*125047198/545180810059;
100*6713682043/545180810059;
100*120523625541/545180810059;
100*351880075357/545180810059;


12.0947727255594
0.0229368304409811
1.23145971375505
22.107092420945
64.5437383092995

In [45]:
# 87% of views are high positive

In [46]:
100*(articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(dissonance)][1][,c('dissonant_views')]/articles_by_pop[,sum(as.numeric(page_views))])


dissonant_views
13.82935

In [47]:
100*(articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(dissonance)][2][,c('dissonant_views')]/articles_by_pop[,sum(as.numeric(page_views))])


dissonant_views
0.6361012

In [48]:
100*(articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(dissonance)][3][,c('dissonant_views')]/articles_by_pop[,sum(as.numeric(page_views))])


dissonant_views
0.0196694

In [49]:
100*(articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(dissonance)][4][,c('dissonant_views')]/articles_by_pop[,sum(as.numeric(page_views))])


dissonant_views
39.31816

In [50]:
100*(articles_by_pop[, list(dissonant_views=sum(page_views)), by=list(dissonance)][5][,c('dissonant_views')]/articles_by_pop[,sum(as.numeric(page_views))])


dissonant_views
46.19671